Most days, I enjoy sifting through the latest research into weight loss, health, fitness, etc…
But not today.
Today I read a study that dooms Mr. Balloon Belly here to a lifetime of popping diet pills and undergoing gastric bypass surgery.
The Research
In this study, researchers used an MRI machine to determine each participant’s level of belly and liver fat along with a blood test to determine insulin sensitivity.
Then, they put all 243 of the test subjects on a nine month lifestyle intervention program which reduced fat intake to a maximum of 30 percent of total calories (including less than 10 percent in the form of saturated fat) and had them engage in moderate physical activity such as walking for at least three hours a week.
Eat less (fat) & move more….classic.
The Results
The patients who started with the most belly fat & were the most insulin insensitive and who were most at risk of developing Type 2 Diabetes did the worst on this lifestyle intervention program.
“The participants who improved their health status as a result of diet and exercise started out with lower baseline levels of abdominal and liver fat.”
Their Conclusion
The researchers concluded that patients with a high level of belly fat & a high level of insulin insensitivity were unlikely to ever be successful at improving their situation with lifestyle modification.
Ever.
Ergo…to lose weight, they would need the help of pharmaceuticals and/or weight loss surgery.
My Conclusion
The lifestyle modification plan used in this experiment is crap.
If you want to improve insulin sensitivity, you don’t modify fat intake…you modify carbohydrate intake.
- Carbs = sugar
- Too much sugar = insulin insensitivity
- Insulin insensitivity = belly & liver fat
- Insulin insensitivity = type 2 diabetes
So, before the medical community tells Mr. Balloon Belly that he is doomed to a life of gastric bypass and anal leakage, perhaps they should retire their old school food pyramids and learn something from us non-experts.
Thus endeth the rant…thanks for listening.
.
Reference






Just wanted to add my unsolicited two cents real quick! My dad is 73 years old and a few years ago was taken to the emergency room from his doctor's office. The result was that he had had a mild stroke and required a pace maker and that his blood sugar was over 500! Dr.'s were amazed that he wasn't in a coma or dead and had to inject insulin directly into his IV for a week to get him stabilized.
My dad was required to go to a "diabetes" class, get a blood glucose meter, and take Januvia, an oral medication. I, out of curiosity, wanted to go to the class with my dad. I was shocked to learn how many people had no clue about what a carb or protein source was. Even more surprising, the instructor - a licensed dietician mind you - told one woman she could still have her cinnamon roll but to just had some protein to it. I couldn't help myself and became a disruptive class member in the sense that I challenged most of what the dietician said. All in all, my dad was sent home to fend for himself.
Recently I find that my dad's blood sugar is regularly in the 220's after he wakes up in the morning. I also found out that at his last Dr.'s appointment he was told that if it couldn't be brought under control that he would require insulin. I couldn't take it any more. I talked my parents in allowing me to do all the cooking and grocery shopping. My dad's favorite snack? Ritz crackers and Jif peanut butter. He had no clue how much sugar and carbs he was getting! I threw them out. I got rid of my mom's bags of chips, my dad's pretzels, their bread, and all the hydrogenated dips they so adored. They were in shock and a bit pissed off at first but I told them they had to be all in or not at all.
They not eat 5-6 smaller meals throughout the day. No one misses breakfast. All carbs were removed from their diet for the first week and they ate lots of chicken, fish, and veggies. My dad's favorite snack of Ritz crackers and Jif peanut butter were replaced with celery and a no sugar added peanut butter. Then I started to add in some low glycemic fruits, however, my dad does better with a half of grapefruit or 1/2 apple and can't handle any more than that or any other type of fruit. My mom has lost 55 pounds and my dad's blood sugar is consistently around 120-122 in the mornings and nor higher than the 130's after eating.
My dad's doctor was shocked at his last appointment. My dad is sold that diet is a powerful tool and feels much better now that his blood sugar is under control and now thinks all doctors are quacks. Diet does have a strong impact on all processes in the body!! There is no excuse for doctors to push pills and insulin over diet changes other than the money they make from doing so! We need more doctors out there that truly want to help people through proper nutrition!
That's my rant!
-TT
- spam
- offensive
- disagree
- off topic
Like