Posts Tagged ‘protein shake’

Nutrition Deathmatch #2: Special K Protein Shake v.s. Chocolate Milk

October 29th, 2009

special k protein shake vs chocolate milk

I think it’s time for me to find another health club.

Yesterday, while chatting with the “towel lady”, I noticed that they were carrying a new protein shake…..by Kellogg’s…  the makers of Eggo waffles, Froot Loops and Pop Tarts.

and now they’re making protein shakes.

I asked to take a look at a bottle of the NEW!!! Special K Protein Shake.

Arrrggghhhhh!!!

Here’s what the label looked like:

special k protein shake chocolate nutrition 2

Looks pretty good, right?

I mean, except for the sucralose, corn syrup solids, acesulfame potassium, nutritive and nonnutritive sweeteners.

On the plus side, it has 190 calories, some carbs to re-fuel after your workout and a relatively small dose of protein.

Just like chocolate milk.

chocolate milk low fat nutrition

In fact, the macronutrient profile looks almost identical to the carton of chocolate milk that I picked up at the 7-11 across the street from the gym.

Calories about the same, protein about the same, carbs about the same. The milk had a lower fat content as I prefer the low-fat version post-workout.

So, why in the world would I spend $3.99 for a bottle of Special K Protein Shake with extra HFCS and nonnutritive sweeteners when I can get a carton of chocolate milk for $1.25?

special k web site

I mean, besides the fact that Kelloggs is marketing their entire Special K product line as an effective way to get healthy….

and look like an airbrushed supermodel in short shorts.

But, maybe you’re not the kind of person who would fall for such obvious commercial manipulation.

Maybe you rely on the opinions of real people…like these bloggers:

Either way, Kelloggs is working hard and spending a lot of money trying to convince you to buy the protein shakes and their healthy cereals and snack bars.

So, as a counterpoint to the advertising, I would like to offer my review of the Special K Protein Shake:

Don’t waste your money.

Chocolate milk is healthier and cheaper.

.

If you like what you see here, click here for updates

.

Related Posts



Popularity: 3% [?]

The Transformation Begins

August 11th, 2008

In Friday’s post, I introduced you to a friend of mine who has decided that he is sick and tired of being fat and wants to enter his 40s with a Super Body.

You know what I’m talking about.

A little less like this:

and a little more like this:

The Challenge

When I am setting up a training and diet plan for a client, my biggest concerns are;

  • The clients level of commitment
  • The clients lifestyle
  • Restrictions – dietary, injuries, time, etc…

In this case, I have little to no restrictions.

  • The client is willing to do anything and everything I say.
  • The client is used to training hard. While I will change his workouts to maximize fat loss, he should be able to handle the workload.
  • The new training program will actually capitalize on his very deep base of strength.
  • He is his own boss and sets his own hours, so he should be able to eat what I tell him to and when I tell him to eat it.
  • His injuries are manageable.
  • And since we also have made a little friendly wager on this transformation, he has even more motivation to do exactly what I tell him.

Client Bio

I was hoping to have my buddy upload before, during and after pictures to the blog, but apparently he is camera shy. More than camera shy, he also does not want his name used.

So, we will have to make due with measurements and a pseudonym.

Measurement Date:  August 11, 2008

Client: Mr. Big Baby

  • Height:  5′ 11″
  • Weight:  271 lbs.
  • Lean Body Mass:  214.75 lbs.
  • Fat Mass:  56.25 lbs.
  • Body fat Percentage:  20.8%
  • Chest:  52.5″
  • Waist:  46.25″ @ widest point – his ‘love handles’
  • Hips:  45″ @ widest point – around his glutes
  • Forearm:  15″

The Goal

  • Weight:  240 lbs
  • Lean Body Mass:  215 lbs.
  • Fat Mass:  25 lbs
  • Body fat percentage:  10%

The Workout Plan

I will outline his training program in more detail in a future post. Here are the highlights:

  • No cardio training
  • No maximal lifting
  • Short duration HIIT training
  • Lots of body weight exercises
  • Varied levels of workout volume
  • Varied levels of workout intensity – focus on speed over poundage
  • Lots of mobility and muscular balance work
  • Increased demand on nervous system
  • Increase the non-weight room activities

The Diet

First off, I want everyone reading this to remember that I am NOT a doctor, dietitian or nutritionist. This diet works like gangbusters in melting away body fat, but I am sure that you family doctor would tell you that you would be nuts to eat in this manner.He may be right.

So there, you have been warned. To continue…

The diet I am giving to Mr. Big Baby is strict.

Four weeks of protein shakes, fish oil and fiber.

This is followed by a four week transition period.

During the transition period, we will gradually increase his solid meals, decrease his shakes and in essence complete his dietary transformation from a bread and cheese-o-holic to a fruit, vegetable and lean protein eating health nut.

He’s kind of like a butterfly.

Currently, he is like a larval caterpillar.

With this diet, he is entering the pupal stage, where he will transform into the final stage:

Based upon his current weight, lean body mass and goal weight, for the next 4 weeks, his daily intake will consist of:

  • 5 Protein Shakes (we are using a multi-protein blend for slower digestion)
  • 5 tbsp. of molecularly distilled fish oil
  • 1 – 3 PGX softgels with each shake
  • 1 tbsp. flax seeds with each shake
  • Multi-Vitamin / Mineral support
  • 200 calories Anti-oxidant drink with every resistance training workout

This works out to:

  • 2050 calories on regular days
  • 2250 calories on resistance training days
  • 200 grams of protein
  • 87 grams of fat
  • 60 grams of carbs on regular days
  • 110 grams of carbs on resistance training days

What else?

Mr. Big Baby is off to his doctor today for blood tests. Considering he hadn’t been to the doctor in 3 years, I insisted he go to see her before starting this diet.

We also discussed the psychological side of diets in general and this nasty S.O.B. in particular. I will discuss this side of the project in tomorrows post.

So, if everything goes well at the doctor, we begin the transformation tomorrow.

We will check in once a week.

If you like what you see here, click here for updates or Share this Post with the rest of the world.

Thanks.

Popularity: 1% [?]

Top Sites Fitness